diff --git a/app/Http/Controllers/Forms/FormUpCountryController.php b/app/Http/Controllers/Forms/FormUpCountryController.php
index 3546f3a..f91c894 100644
--- a/app/Http/Controllers/Forms/FormUpCountryController.php
+++ b/app/Http/Controllers/Forms/FormUpCountryController.php
@@ -333,12 +333,12 @@ class FormUpCountryController extends Controller
     $phoneNumbers = array_unique($phoneNumbers);
 
     // // Send bulk email
-    Mail::to($recipients)->send(new ExpenseApproved(
-      $name,
-      $expense_number,
-      $tanggal,
-      $total
-    ));
+    // Mail::to($recipients)->send(new ExpenseApproved(
+    //   $name,
+    //   $expense_number,
+    //   $tanggal,
+    //   $total
+    // ));
 
     // send whatsapp message
     WhatsappHelper::approveExpense($phoneNumbers, $expense_number);
@@ -382,12 +382,12 @@ class FormUpCountryController extends Controller
     $phoneNumbers = array_unique($phoneNumbers);
 
     // Send bulk email
-    Mail::to($recipients)->send(new ExpenseRejected(
-      $name,
-      $expense_number,
-      $tanggal,
-      $total
-    ));
+    // Mail::to($recipients)->send(new ExpenseRejected(
+    //   $name,
+    //   $expense_number,
+    //   $tanggal,
+    //   $total
+    // ));
 
     // send whatsapp message
     WhatsappHelper::rejectExpense($phoneNumbers, $expense_number);
@@ -438,12 +438,12 @@ class FormUpCountryController extends Controller
     $phoneNumbers = array_unique($phoneNumbers);
 
     // Send bulk email
-    Mail::to($recipients)->send(new FinalApprove(
-      $name,
-      $expense_number,
-      $tanggal,
-      $total
-    ));
+    // Mail::to($recipients)->send(new FinalApprove(
+    //   $name,
+    //   $expense_number,
+    //   $tanggal,
+    //   $total
+    // ));
 
     // send whatsapp message
     WhatsappHelper::finalApprove($phoneNumbers, $expense_number);